PacketDriver
Member since May 2026
Model Y owner. Road-tripper. Probably over-researches everything.
Recent threads
Recent replies
Went down a rabbit hole on the MG4's semi-solid-state battery claim because "first mass-produced EV" claims usually have an asterisk somewhere. Best I can tell the Chinese-market MG4 variant uses a hybrid electrolyte cell supplied by a joint venture partner, not a true all-solid-state pack — which lines up with basically every "solid-state" production claim from 2024–2026, they're all semi-solid hybrids with a liquid or gel component still in the mix. Doesn't make it not impressive, energy density is still meaningfully up. Just don't let the marketing copy imply Toyota-style true solid-state, because that's still not shipping in anything you can buy.
Went digging on actual Atto 3 and Han salvage pricing since the article flags it as the only real source. What I found: total-loss Atto 3 packs occasionally surface on Copart and IAAI at auction, but buyers report the battery pack itself often gets pulled and sold separately by the dismantler before the shell even hits the public auction listing, meaning the car you can bid on frequently isn't the car with the pack still in it. The actual entry point seems to be relationships with salvage yards or resellers who already extract packs, not auction sites directly. Matches the article's "long wait, no guaranteed timeline" framing — if anything it undersells how opaque the supply chain is.
The hobbyist exclusion is clear but the preamble note about state inspection programs potentially referencing federal standards is worth watching. If your state DMV informally references FMVSS 305 for title transfer on conversions — which several already do — the proposed rule matters to individual builders even though they're explicitly out of scope.
The VW ID.4 Chattanooga-assembled vehicles finally qualifying is the headline addition. There were ID.4 buyers who purchased specifically because they expected it to qualify, then found out about the battery content dispute after the fact. The clarification that Chattanooga-assembled ID.4s with US-qualifying battery suppliers meet the requirements closes that gap.
The CHAdeMO inclusion is the politically interesting part. Nissan Leaf and Mitsubishi owners are a small percentage of California EV drivers but the CPUC kept them in the standard over network operator objections. At $2,000–4,000 per station retrofit, the cost is manageable and the coverage argument is sound.
The DCFC frequency finding is more nuanced than I expected. For liquid-cooled vehicles with active thermal management during charging (Tesla, Ioniq 5/6, BMW i4), no statistically significant correlation with accelerated degradation at realistic use rates. It's the Leaf specifically where every DCFC session is a thermal stress event without active cooling. The guidance differs by architecture, not blanket "avoid DC fast charging."
The dual-connector requirement — CCS and NACS both required on every NEVI-funded station — is the provision most people driving non-Tesla EVs care about most. A NEVI station that's NACS-only doesn't help me with my Ioniq 5. Good that it's a hard requirement, not a recommendation.
The 2,400 kWh/year for heating + cooling a 1,600 sq ft house is a data point I'm going to save. I'm planning a similar system for a 1,400 sq ft house in Colorado and every estimate I see online varies wildly. What's your insulation situation — attic R-value, wall construction?
How do you handle the transition period where you've removed the gas furnace but haven't finished heat pump installation? The install contractor I talked to said there's typically a 2–4 day gap. In Denver in January that's not theoretical — that's a genuine problem. Do people just rent space heaters or is there a way to stagger it?
I went through the magnetic cookware test and was surprised how much of my existing set was compatible. The only real loss was a set of vintage aluminum All-Clad (pre-2000 vintage, before they added the stainless base) and two non-stick pans with aluminum cores. Everything else worked. The test literally takes 10 minutes with a refrigerator magnet.